China’s mix of historical and legal claims in the South China Sea are inconsistent, says Frank Ching. Beijing can’t have its cake and eat it.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/88661/886613c3a0f69c938ec2847422bcc493ef545197" alt="Abusing History?"
US scholar Lucian Pye once famously said that China was not a country but ‘a civilization pretending to be a state.’ That may have been apt at one time, but today’s China has been transformed into a modern state that plays an active role in international forums.